Illustration

Fantastic Toyage

vintage toy & collectibles store

Massapequa, NYOpen 5 days a weekOpen Sundays

From its website: vintage and collectible toys, collectible dolls and sports and trading cards.

  • Toys
  • Dolls
  • Trading cards
  • Layaway
  • 5288 Merrick Rd, Massapequa, NY 11758
  • (516) 882-9250
  • Monday 12 pm–7 pm, Thursday 12 pm–7 pm, Friday 12 pm–8 pm, Saturday 11 am–8 pm…
Call (516) 882-9250Directions

About Fantastic Toyage

Fantastic Toyage is a vintage toy & collectibles store at 5288 Merrick Rd in Massapequa, NY.

What it says it carries: vintage and collectible toys, collectible dolls and sports and trading cards. Services named on the site: layaway.

It is usually open Monday 12 pm–7 pm, Thursday 12 pm–7 pm, Friday 12 pm–8 pm, Saturday 11 am–8 pm and Sunday 12 pm–6 pm; closed Tuesday and Wednesday. Sunday hours make it an easy weekend stop. The number is (516) 882-9250; small shops sometimes close early, so a quick call saves a wasted trip.

Outside Massapequa, the closest stop is Long Island Antiques Center (Merrick), 6.3 miles away. If you want more booths to browse, Sea City Vintage, an antique mall, is 16 miles away.

What it sells and does

  • Toys
  • Dolls
  • Trading cards
  • Layaway
  • …Indiana Jones, Nightmare Before Christmas, Bobble Heads, Sports Card Memorabilia, Trading Cards, Power Rangers, Simpson, Betty Boop, Transformers, Action Figures, Beatles, Kiss, Barbie, Pez, Luckboxes, Collectible Plates, Match Box Cars,…Toys · source page
  • …Christmas, Bobble Heads, Sports Card Memorabilia, Trading Cards, Power Rangers, Simpson, Betty Boop, Transformers, Action Figures, Beatles, Kiss, Barbie, Pez, Luckboxes, Collectible Plates, Match Box Cars, Hot Wheels, Models and the list…Dolls · source page
  • …Star Wars, but also Star Trek, Lord of the Rings, Disney, GI Joes, Indiana Jones, Nightmare Before Christmas, Bobble Heads, Sports Card Memorabilia, Trading Cards, Power Rangers, Simpson, Betty Boop, Transformers, Action Figures, Beatles,…Trading cards · source page
  • Ask about our FREE layaway planLayaway · source page

Based on quotes from its own website (October 2026). Stock changes constantly; ask about specific pieces.

Advertisement

Fantastic Toyage and nearby antique stops

Loading map…

Map: Leaflet · map data © OpenStreetMap contributors.

Get directions · Copper pin: this shop; dark pins: other listed shops nearby.

Before you go

  • Check the hours on the day: small antique shops often close early or take a day off midweek.
  • Inspect pieces in good light: look for repairs, replaced parts and later finishes.
  • A polite "is this your best price?" is normal at most independent shops.

Questions about Fantastic Toyage

Where is Fantastic Toyage?

Fantastic Toyage is at 5288 Merrick Rd, Massapequa, NY 11758.

Is Fantastic Toyage open on Sundays?

Yes, its listed Sunday hours are 12 pm–6 pm. Call (516) 882-9250 to confirm.

What does Fantastic Toyage sell?

Its website mentions vintage and collectible toys, collectible dolls and sports and trading cards. Stock changes all the time, so ask about specific pieces.

Nearby antique stores

Keep exploring