Illustration

The Toy Pit

vintage toy & collectibles store

Indianapolis, INOpen 6 days a weekOpen Sundays

From its website: vintage and collectible toys, collectible dolls and comic books.

  • Toys
  • Dolls
  • Comics
  • Retro games
  • Buys antiques
  • 3827 N College Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46205
  • (317) 703-8697
  • Tuesday to Friday 11 am–6:30 pm, Saturday 10:30 am–6 pm and Sunday 12 pm–6 pm…
Call (317) 703-8697Directions

About The Toy Pit

The Toy Pit is a vintage toy & collectibles store at 3827 N College Ave in Indianapolis, IN. Its website dates the business to 2009.

What it says it carries: vintage and collectible toys, collectible dolls, comic books and retro video games. Services named on the site: buys antiques and collections.

It is usually open Tuesday to Friday 11 am–6:30 pm, Saturday 10:30 am–6 pm and Sunday 12 pm–6 pm; closed Monday. Sunday hours make it an easy weekend stop. Before you set out, ring (317) 703-8697 to check it's open.

We list 36 other shops in Indianapolis, so you can make a day of it.

What it sells and does

  • Toys
  • Dolls
  • Comics
  • Retro games
  • Buys antiques
  • MODERN/VINTAGE ACTION FIGURESToys · source page
  • …offering something for everyone — from Star Wars, Marvel, DC, Transformers, and Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles to Godzilla, Dragon Ball, Hello Kitty, Barbie, Hot Toys, and vintage video gamesDolls · source page
  • RARE COMIC BOOKSComics · source page
  • VINTAGE VIDEO GAMESRetro games · source page
  • WE BUY, SELL & TRADEBuys antiques · source page
  • Founded in 2009 in Fort Wayne, The Toy Pit began with one simple idea — to create a space where toy collectors could connect, share their passion, and rediscover the joy of collectingFounded · source page

Based on quotes from its own website (October 2026). Stock changes constantly; ask about specific pieces.

Advertisement

The Toy Pit and nearby antique stops

Loading map…

Map: Leaflet · map data © OpenStreetMap contributors.

Get directions · Copper pin: this shop; dark pins: other listed shops nearby.

Before you go

  • Confirm it's open before a long drive; independent shops change hours with the season.
  • Ask about a piece's history; dealers often know where it came from.
  • Many shops will hold a piece for a day or two if you ask.
  • Selling? Send clear photos first and ask how they price what they buy.

Questions about The Toy Pit

Where is The Toy Pit?

The Toy Pit is at 3827 N College Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46205.

Is The Toy Pit open on Sundays?

Yes, its listed Sunday hours are 12 pm–6 pm. Call (317) 703-8697 to confirm.

What does The Toy Pit sell?

Its website mentions vintage and collectible toys, collectible dolls, comic books and retro video games. Stock changes all the time, so ask about specific pieces.

Does The Toy Pit buy antiques?

Buying is mentioned its website. Call or send photos before bringing items in.

More antique stops in Indianapolis

All 37 shops in Indianapolis

Keep exploring