Illustration

Aronstam Jewelers

antique & estate jewelry store

Carmel, INOpen 5 days a week

From its website: vintage and estate jewelry, paintings, prints and folk art and sterling and silver plate.

  • Jewelry
  • Art & prints
  • Silver
  • Buys antiques
  • Appraisals
  • 200 S Rangeline Rd #217, Carmel, IN 46032
  • (317) 817-9000
  • Tuesday to Friday 10 am–6 pm and Saturday 11:30 am–5 pm; closed Monday and…
Call (317) 817-9000Directions

About Aronstam Jewelers

Based at 200 S Rangeline Rd #217 in Carmel, IN, Aronstam Jewelers is an antique & estate jewelry store.

Its website mentions vintage and estate jewelry, paintings, prints and folk art and sterling and silver plate. Beyond the sales floor, the site lists buys antiques and collections and appraisals.

Opening hours on record: Tuesday to Friday 10 am–6 pm and Saturday 11:30 am–5 pm; closed Monday and Sunday. Call (317) 817-9000 to confirm hours before a long drive.

We list 3 other shops in Carmel, so you can make a day of it. The nearest listed shop outside Carmel is Midwest Jewelry and Bullion in Indianapolis, about 3.5 miles away. For many dealers under one roof, Carmel Old Town Antique Mall is under a mile away.

What it sells and does

  • Jewelry
  • Art & prints
  • Silver
  • Buys antiques
  • Appraisals
  • “Marc designed a diamond-shaped white gold pendant for me, knowing how much I love the look of antique jewelryJewelry · source page
  • I have always felt a part of the ‘Aronstam family.’ Beautiful, custom jewelry gives me pleasure like a piece of fine artArt & prints · source page
  • We Buy Gold, Sterling Silver & PlatinumSilver · source page
  • We Buy Gold!!!Buys antiques · source page
  • Estate & Insurance AppraisalsAppraisals · source page

Based on quotes from its own website (October 2026). Stock changes constantly; ask about specific pieces.

Advertisement

Aronstam Jewelers and nearby antique stops

Loading map…

Map: Leaflet · map data © OpenStreetMap contributors.

Get directions · Copper pin: this shop; dark pins: other listed shops nearby.

Before you go

  • Confirm it's open before a long drive; independent shops change hours with the season.
  • Ask for a written description of age, metal and stones with any significant purchase.
  • If you're selling, call first and ask whether they buy outright or take items on consignment.
  • Selling? Send clear photos first and ask how they price what they buy.

Questions about Aronstam Jewelers

Where is Aronstam Jewelers?

Aronstam Jewelers is at 200 S Rangeline Rd #217, Carmel, IN 46032.

Is Aronstam Jewelers open on Sundays?

No, it is listed as closed on Sundays. Call (317) 817-9000 to confirm.

What does Aronstam Jewelers sell?

Its website mentions vintage and estate jewelry, paintings, prints and folk art and sterling and silver plate. Stock changes all the time, so ask about specific pieces.

Does Aronstam Jewelers buy antiques?

Buying is mentioned its website. Call or send photos before bringing items in.

Does Aronstam Jewelers do appraisals?

Appraisals are mentioned its website. Ask whether it's a verbal opinion or a written appraisal, and what it costs.

More antique stops in Carmel

Nearby antique stores

Keep exploring